Adoption is forever…

October 2, 2009

…unless it turns out to be sorta hard and you’re tired and you have five of your *own* children, and then maybe it’s not forever, and you can totally return the goods. Well, not return them, but sort of resale them, but not for money. But at least you can be free of them.

Or that’s my take home message after reading the BS explanation given by a “mom” who gave up on her adopted BABY in such a short period of time it makes my head spin. You can read about it here.

I’m writing a super, super long post about it. It’s half way done, painfully long, and disjointed. And I’m packing for Vegas (!) for a weekend trip (because, seriously, I need the two day break right now after the past four weeks), and so it will have to wait until I get back. Trust me, I can’t leg this go.

For now, I’ll just post what I put up on Facebook. As I said, I have a long, long opinion on this. The short version is that the “issues” she noted that made it so difficult to bond with that baby were so minor in my mind it’s laughable. I only wish Matty had had those problems. I kept reading people’s comments along the lines of, “Until you’ve walked a mile in her shoes, don’t judge.” Well, I’ve walked a mile. I kept walking. I didn’t throw the fucking shoes away. She did.

I’d love your thoughts, and on Monday, I’ll put my full post up. For now, a VERY abbreviated opinion:

I have SO many issues with this situation. First and foremost, this child is FAR better off in a home with *real* parents who are capable of being selfless and loving toward a child that is their OWN. That woman did not deserve this baby, never should have been granted the privilege of raising him, and so I couldn’t care less about her now – he’s in a MUCH  better place. Unfortunately, she made the super STUPID decision in the first place to adopt (I have my opinions on her motivation), and so this child has been screwed and rejected twice. No matter how she tries to spin this situation, she’s selfish. If she weren’t, she wouldn’t have put this kids’ huge heartache, loss, and rejection out there for the world to read about.
Second, this highlights my HUGE issue with adoption agencies and social workers. She should have easily been screened out. Aside from her obvious issues, the family situation was such that an adoption probably wasn’t a good idea. However, nobody from the home study agency shows up at your house and asks the hard questions, like “Hey, you just might adopt a BABY that has been neglected and abused, engages in upsetting self soothing behaviors, is angry, won’t want you to hold him, will hit you, won’t make eye contact, needs a lot of time and effort to bond, might not sleep more than half an hour at a time, might have physical and developmental delays that will require lots of speech and occupational and physical therapy, and might take over a year to begin to resemble what you’d call a “happy, adjusted” child. So, you up for the challenge?” And then if someone’s not, the AGENCY should not accept them. But that’s easy for me to say when I’m not collecting tens of thousands of dollars as a brokering service, right? Adoption is a multi-billion dollar business. The idea of doing the right thing, well, that’s just crazy talk. (Except the agency we used for Molley? They do that.  They don’t hide anything. They give the worst case scenario. I was shocked in the best way possible. Novel, huh?)
And finally, if you google her name, in my opinion, it becomes quickly and painfully obvious why she is doing this. Attention, publicity seeking behavior. Disruptions of YOUNG BABIES (under one year) who are PHYSICALLY healthy are not common. She’s not out there for the similarly situated family to see and relate to. She’s looking to make a bigger name for herself and promote herself and her career, as far as I can tell.
Told you this was abbreviated. My real post is 3,000 words and counting. If you’ve read my blog for any length of time, you know that what we went through during Matty’s first year with us was the most difficult thing I’ve done in my life. I’ve never given the full picture here, nor will I, but I think it’s fair to say that it was anything but easy.
But we made a commitment. He wasn’t a puppy from the pound or a car from the dealership. He was a BABY that Ed and I committed to raising. And you know what? It was a year. One year. One little, tiny fucking year. And now? One year of exhaustion, not sleeping, being sick, being emotionally and physically beat up, worn down, and crushed was a down payment on our entire future with an INCREDIBLE little boy who is so full of love and joy and happiness that I often don’t have the words to convey my feelings. It took me a full year to completely and totally feel like his mom. Now? Oh my gosh, I don’t even know where to start. He is the most incredible son a mother could want. He makes my world go round. He and Molley (with whom I am still building the strong attachment I now have with Matty) are the most incredible people born. Really, they are. Does that feeling come instantly for everyone? Sure didn’t for me? Do you give up because it didn’t? I think you know how I feel about that.
(Also, so many people who have adopted and who support her adopted OLDER children, not babies. you cannot compare the two situations. A baby under a year is very, very different than a child or a teenager.)
My bottom line is that she had no business with this baby, shouldn’t have made such a careless decision to adopt in the first place, shouldn’t have been approved by an agency, and did the (pathetic, cop out, but ultimately) right thing FOR THE BABY after it became apparent to her that she was a selfish person, but had NO BUSINESS putting his tragic situation out there for the world to learn about and is not entitled to public support whatsoever. (Why weren’t the real, tough questions asked of her in the new interview, BTW?)  It’s 2009; this WILL catch up to that little boy. Google her. Seriously, do it. Form an opinion on why she wrote it. Then tell me what you think.

Entry Filed under: Uncategorized. .

22 Comments Add your own

  • 1. 3continentfamily  |  October 2, 2009 at 10:44 pm

    Just read that article and am so sick to my stomach I can’t even process my thoughts clearly. I will not be one of those patting her on the back saying she is brave.

    I did leave a comment- maybe it will be published (they are being monitored). Here it is for prosperity (very early here so it’s not written very well!!)

    I don’t know where to begin. I am an adoptive parent and I am not going to praise you or thank you for being so brave.
    It is very clear that neither your adoption agency or social worker did a very good job screening you and/or preparing your for adoption. What in God’s name were your motivations? That it would be a ‘nice’ thing to ‘do’?

    Part of me is so horrifically angry that you gave up on this child and decided that he was disposable simply because he was not biologically yours. Another part of me is relieved he is out of your house, away from you and with a loving family.

    That you mention your girls were so indifferent towards him is frightening in and of itself. If he had stayed with you, he would have been treated and felt like an outcast.

    I understand that bonding can be hard. But that process is not about how YOU feel, or how hard it is for YOU. You started getting worried after 5 months of it still being difficult? It can be a good solid year depending on how old your child is at the time of adoption to start really seeing solid connection. It is supporting, loving and being there for your child every second of every day- committing to building trust and love.

    I hope D is happy now. Your agency should be shut down and your social worker who completed your homestudy be fired.

    Reply
  • 2. Julie and Dean  |  October 3, 2009 at 4:37 am

    Honestly, we wouldn’t even give one of our dogs back. We have one dog that has caused us so much trauma and drama and has actually jeaopardized our relatoinships w/others (no lie here, this dog is crazy) but we “adopted” him from the shelter and we are 100% committed to him. I’ m not an intense dog lover either, it’s all about integrity.
    REGARDING the abandoning of an adopted child, It hurts to read that story and I ache for the child. I also hate the image it projects about adoption and attachment issues. Why the hell wasn’t I on the news about how well my baby and I bond??? Senssationalism, got to love the media.
    My thoughts are usually off than everyone elses and I try not to start firestorms. I think of the horrible way my son was abandoned (left on the street in VN in a CLOSED box to die on the day he was born) yet I still do not feel anger towards his birthparents…
    Ok I have to stop because I don’t believe I can effectively communicate my thoughts here .
    Bottom line: The mom who abandonded her adopted son was wrong and there is no way we can try to rationalize the actions of an irrational individual. AndI agree that this child was let down by many people on so many levels.
    What can we do to prevent these type of situations from happening because quite honestly this is not the first time I have heard this same type of story?.

    Reply
  • 3. Sarah  |  October 3, 2009 at 6:51 am

    The publicity angle of this is disgusting. Did you read this blog post?

    http://chinaadoptiontalk.blogspot.com/2009/08/terminating-adoption-will-real-anita.html

    So many weird inconsistencies. I agree that any agency worth their salt should have passed on this woman, or at the very least recommended a year or so of education and counseling before approving their homestudy.

    I find her creepy, and really feel for her son, and hope he’s in a better situation now.

    But why have so many different versions of the story out there? She seems like a fame whore. Just gross.

    Reply
  • 4. Lawmommy  |  October 3, 2009 at 11:09 am

    I don’t know what I want to say about this. Part of me is angry with her with saying she didn’t love him like she loved her biological children, because it perpetuates the idea that it’s impossible to love an adopted child the same as a biological child…part of me is appalled that a family with 5 children and one parent literally putting his life on the line and rarely home added another child into a such a stressful situation…the thing that upsets me the most is that the child’s siblings watched SpongeBob and said good-bye casually…that image is so disturbing to me.

    But the bottom line, I guess, is that the child deserved to be with a family who could love him and I hope that’s where he is now. But as a parent who has both biological and adopted kids…I kind of want to kick her…

    Reply
  • 5. rachel  |  October 3, 2009 at 12:47 pm

    this story makes me really really angry because I do believe there are LEGITIMATE reasons for disruption. I see them, often. there are VERY MUCH good reasons for disrupting, and this woman is claiming to have one, and I want to hurl.

    She had two biological babies in the process of adopting “D”. TWO. So she was post-partum, TWICE. She was hormonal TWICE. And she didn’t understand why her adopted child didn’t just sit quietly in his crib and play nicely while she attended to the other children.

    I do not think she should have been allowed to adopt; she was the essentially single mother to four, then five, bio kids. (Her husband is in the military.)

    And I TOTALLY agree with you, Laura – she is an attention-seeking, narcissist. TOTALLY. And no, I haven’t walked in her shoes, but I don’t think she should ever have been allowed to adopt in the first place. I’m sure D is better off now. No doubt. But he shouldn’t have had to endure the first placement…

    There is another blog that has this opinion of her, too – racialicious, maybe? I forget the actual URL but it will come up in a Google search.

    Reply
  • 6. klarobinson215  |  October 3, 2009 at 12:59 pm

    I’m so glad you can write so clearley when you are mad – I just want to scream! All I can say is that my heart goes out to that little boy.

    Reply
  • 7. thefivepumpkins  |  October 3, 2009 at 6:25 pm

    I am sick sick sick to my stomach, seriously. WTF? I guess the only “positive” is that D is now with a family that seems to understand HIS needs and are in it for the long haul and know it is going to take some time.

    How does this happen? I don’t even understand how she was allowed to adopt with her husband out of the country and all of their problems. I couldn’t believe all the questions our social worker asked us and how much info we had to provide. Granted, I understand it and am glad she did but obviously, there is a huge difference in agencies.

    What a bunch of bs…

    Reply
  • 8. Katherine  |  October 3, 2009 at 6:58 pm

    So so so awful. She should be examined by Child Welfare to see what she is doing to her other kids to make them such uncaring, indifferent people. Disgusting.

    I feel exactly the same as you. I am physically ill right now, just from reading the article.

    I would love to know what agency they used.

    Reply
  • 9. Erica  |  October 3, 2009 at 7:44 pm

    This case is deeply disturbing. As someone already stated, her comments about not loving this child like her bio kids highlighted a negative perception that many people have–adopted kids are a second choice.

    I’ve never been pregnant, but from what I have heard from those who adopted after first having a bio child, it is more challenging. You don’t have that automatic love like you do for a child that you have carried for 9 months. Too many people think that bio and adopted kids are the same, that you treat them the same. You don’t. It’s not the same.

    The fact that she already had 5 other children in the home and her husband wasn’t even around–well, it seems like a recipe for disaster. Some days I feel like I struggle and it is just one child. I can’t imagine having 5 and another child that I have to work at attachment with and help with delays.

    This is very sad. I feel for that little boy and I hope he is happy with his now family.

    Reply
  • 10. hiking mama  |  October 3, 2009 at 7:55 pm

    Oh my word…this is so terribly disturbing…it makes me sick. I have so much to say about this, but I’ll leave it for later. This woman should have NEVER been allowed to adopt. And seriously?? Who was the social worker and agency?–the best interest of this child was obviously not a concern of theirs. I’m heartbroken for this child, but happy that he has had the chance to find a family that will love him the way he deserves.

    Reply
  • 11. lammmimi  |  October 3, 2009 at 9:14 pm

    I believed this woman, besides her conscien is eating her, she is seeking for attentions, for reasurance that her action is appropriate, a courageous decision, eventhought, will draw much angers, and disgusts from some others, so what!!, she got our attentions. If she truly desires a son, a brother for her daughters, she should discuss with her family, and prepare them for the changes, for the uphill battle, especially a S/N child. Bonding with a child is two way process, it takes more than 1 year, and it is day to day progress. Apparently, she wants a balance picture perfect family wih daughters and son, unfortunately, little D is not the missing piece puzzle she was looking for. Such a shame, she still said she loves him, I hope this boy is too young to remember this, and hope he will not stumble onto her blog years from now…

    Reply
  • 12. Nicki  |  October 3, 2009 at 9:40 pm

    It’s so gross, right? All I can say is that the child clearly deserves to be somewhere else. So at least from that angle, I hope he finally gets the love he deserves. But also there should be a system to mark these (unique, very few) situations where clearly the issue is the parent and they should absolutely not be allowed to adopt again. I really REALLY hope that isn’t even on the table for them.

    Reply
  • 13. Christine  |  October 4, 2009 at 5:11 am

    Speechless. And irate.

    Reply
  • 14. angie  |  October 4, 2009 at 6:16 am

    i need to go read the article, but i had to stop and TOTALLY agree with you about social workers. ours did a fairly good job…she REALLY drilled us. i was annoyed at the time, but after seeing that the social work that my friends and sister used asked NO questions…i was actually happy to be drilled. my sister is adopting a toddler from uganda and was never asked one question about how to deal with race or ANYTHING about raising a toddler and what issue you might experience with that. the social worker was more worried about getting things done quickly and good enough for USCIS to approve. SO infuriating. this is the same thing this social worker that approved two of my friends for domestic babies/open to race.

    okay…off to read the article now…

    Reply
  • 15. gayla  |  October 5, 2009 at 9:16 am

    I’m really speechless. I saw this woman on the Today show last week but had not had the chance to read her article. I think it speaks volumes that her daughters could not be bothered during Spongebob to even say good-bye to their brother.

    I agree 100% that this family should never have been allowed to adopt. How a family with 5 young children and an absent father was allowed to adopt is beyond me. The agency and social worker screwed up royally and a little boy had to pay the price. I am so glad he is out of this home now but find the whole story disturbing and heartbreaking for him. I think the chance of this not affecting him longterm is slim to none.

    Reply
  • 16. Jamie [Phatchik]  |  October 5, 2009 at 10:02 am

    I work in the Human Services field and my area of focus is adoption. I will say, when I first heard this story, I was initially upset. But, after reading the articles and watching the news stories, I’m not upset anymore. I think it’s sad that this woman didn’t feel she could bond to this child or that this child was bonding to her, but in the end [and you said it yourself], “this child is FAR better off in a home with *real* parents who are capable of being selfless and loving toward a child that is their OWN.”

    This woman claims to have sought help, and while I’ll agree, it wasn’t for very long and these types of situations require more than just a few months to rectify, she seems to have been taking some steps in the right direction.

    The truth is, [sadly,] bio-parents do this every day, it’s just not publicized. Every day, they drop their children off at our “safe place” and tell us they are ungovernable or they can’t parent them anymore. It’s sad [HEART WRENCHING!] but it’s true. And what we want more than anything is whatever is in the best interest of the child.

    Reply
  • 17. Angel  |  October 5, 2009 at 7:01 pm

    I think everyone has basically said it all.

    I wonder, if had she had the same problems with one of her bio children, whether she would have relinquished that child? Or was this only ok because the child was adopted?

    Reply
  • 18. Erica  |  October 5, 2009 at 7:21 pm

    I’ve thought more about this and I wonder…if she had had attachment issues with one of her (now 6 it appears) children, would she have placed them for adoption? I think of my own mother and I wonder if it entered her mind when she realized I was not attaching appropriately? I don’t think it did. What does it say to adopted children the world over when we agree to love them only until things get difficult. I keep going back to the perpetuation of “bio kids are best” tone. We have to fight this constantly–in the media, in movies and dumb ass TV shows–why would she get on the Today Show and perpetuate those thoughts all over again?

    This disturbs me the longer I think on it.

    Reply
  • 19. Debbie in the UK  |  October 6, 2009 at 1:24 am

    I cried reading about this. It totally disgusts me and you write to eloquently about things that upset you. Great post and one I wholeheartedly agree with.

    Reply
  • 20. Oscar's mom  |  October 6, 2009 at 11:26 am

    I am still so upset about this that I cannot even get my head wrapped around the issue. I get that “disruption” occurs. I even think that sometimes it might be the best thing – like when a child goes after his sibling or parents with a knife (and I might even say that he’d have to do that repeatedly, but I’m still trying to figure out where I fall here). But because you didn’t “bond”??? When you got pregnant twice, before and after bringing him home??? Need to take a breath and relax again.

    Anyway, my point was to thank you for being honest about this and not doing the politically correct “mile in her shoes” crap. For those of us who have walked that mile, I suspect we understand what she was feeling (or not feeling), but don’t agree with the decision. Nor do we feel it was in “D”s best interest. This child has been cast aside twice. I don’t know how you move past that. The system that was supposed to find him a home has failed him irrevocably.

    Reply
  • 21. jen  |  October 6, 2009 at 8:40 pm

    I posted on this one too. What a load of crap!! Our agency would not do our home study while J was deployed and it sounds like corners were cut that had serious consequences for little D. I wouldn’t treat my dog like this! Hello crazy octomom attention whore?!?

    Reply
  • 22. mostlymorgan  |  October 7, 2009 at 6:17 am

    Check out her post on hoping to make her blog more interesting to generate money. At what cost???

    http://milspouse.wordpress.com/2008/05/21/how-much-to-really-say-in-a-blog/

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Required

Required, hidden

Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Twitter

Etc.

StatCounter

free web tracker

Pages

 

October 2009
M T W T F S S
« Sep   Nov »
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

Archives

a

Meta