• StatCounter

    free web tracker

The things that people say…

There are two things about me that have been consistent throughout my life. I don’t believe these two things will ever change.

   I’m VERY difficult to offend and I’m RARELY rendered speechless.

Well, today, I was speechless.

Because I’m difficult to offend and because I’m rarely speechless, I’ve handled the occasional comments and questions regarding our family with relative ease. I do absolutely want to note that this is due in large part to the fact that Mattix does not yet have the ability to comprehend what others are saying when they ask or comment about him. I’m not sure how I’ll handle things in the future because each of these incidents I’m about to recount would have upset me greatly if my child were old enough to understand the conversations but not yet old enough to have developed a level of comfort with himself and a recognition that the world is full of douche bags who do knot know (or care) that just because you think something doesn’t mean you can say/ask it. Self censorship, people, self censorship (I know I’m preaching that one to the choir here). If you read to the end, I’d really appreciate advice from BTDTs in this regard.

The first incident occurred after we’d been home for a month or so. I was entering a clothing store not too far from our house. We don’t live in a cave or an itty bitty town, by the way. We live in the fifth largest city in the United States with a population of over six million, so our family isn’t exactly a freak show around here.  Mattix and I had walked into the clothing store and there was a guy, maybe in his late 20’s or early 30’s, standing behind a stroller. I have no idea how old the kid in the stroller was because I wasn’t paying attention. I was just walking into a store to shop. His eyes about popped out of his head when he looked in our stroller, saw Mattix, then looked up and saw me. ‘Cause the craziest thing in the world is a pasty white woman with a baby who has darker skin. Okay, whatever, but then his mouth fell open and he actually turned around and smacked his wife’s arm to get her attention, said “Look at that woman…and look at her baby!” and then POINTED AT US.

Now, my initial instinct was of course to appreciate him noticing what a hot, rockin’ mom I was, looking all fabulous and whatnot. Then I remembered that I’ve never been hot in my life, my clothes were wrinkled, my right shoulder was covered in baby food, I had bags under my eyes the size of quarters from lack of sleep, and I hadn’t washed my hair in four days. So that wasn’t it. The woman proceeded to stare at me. All the while, I was walking towards them because they were in the middle of the isle that leads into the store. They just stood there, in the middle of the isle, staring at us.

So I stopped, looked at them, smiled, and said in a friendly tone, “Do I have food stuck in my teeth or something?” and motioned to my mouth.

A few other customers who were nearby witnessing the whole thing, who had the “I can’t believe that this is hapening” look on their faces, laughed out loud. Then I just said, “Excuse me, do you mind if I squeeze by you? Thanks so much!” And they moved over and I’m pretty sure they were speechless.

Okay, no big deal. If Mattix were old enough to understand me but not old enough to notice the stares and blatant pointing, I would have skipped the whole first part and stuck with the “Excuse me, do you mind if I squeeze by you?” thing. If Mattix were old enough to understand me and old enough to notice the stares and pointing, I’m not sure what I would have done. Maybe ignored it and talked to him about it after we left the store?

I wasn’t offended and I wasn’t speechless.

The next notable incident happened in an airport restaurant on the way home from DC. Ed was on a conference call during our entire breakfast and he was in and out of the restaurant depending on the noise level. Our server noted over and over to me how adorable Mattix was. I know he’s adorable. He’s super cute. He’s freaking beautiful. I’m well aware that I’m fully, disgustingly, unobjective. I think he’s the cutest kid in the world, but that’s a mom’s prerogative. I don’t mind other people noticing, either. ‘Cause after all, he IS that cute. However, when she said it for the 15the time, I knew where this was going.

Finally, she couldn’t take it any more. Following is our conversation.

Woman: ”Is he adopted?”

Me: “Yes, we adopted him.”

Woman: “Oh, that’s wonderful. What a lucky boy.”

Me: “Thank you! Yes, it is wonderful for my husband and I. We are so lucky to be his parents. I never knew I’d be so fortunate and I still don’t know what I did to deserve this.”

Woman: “Oh. Well, I think he’s lucky.”

Me: {wanting her to go away, but still using my nice voice} “Well, we know we’re the lucky ones. He’s an amazing kid.”

Woman: “Hmmm. Well, it’s nice. But don’t you want any kids of your own?”

Me: {oh for the love of pete, make it stop. getting very, very difficult for me to keep up the nice voice. pretty sure i switched over to the fake nice voice} “Oh, yes, he is my own. And I do want to adopt a second child.”

Woman: “No, I mean your OWN kids.”

Me: “Yeah, he is my own.”

Woman: {believing that if she raises her voice and overemphasizes particular words, I will suddenly stop being such an idiot and understand what she means} “NO. I mean, don’t you ever want YOUR. OWN. KIDS?”

Me: “I have my own kid. He’s right here. We adopted him and he’s our own child.”

Woman: “No, that’s not what I mean. I MEAN, don’t you want YOUR. OWN KIDS?”

Me: “I know exactly what you mean and he IS. MY. OWN. KID. Do you mind grabbing our check? Our plane is going to board soon.”

Still not offended or speechless. Irritated? Absolutely. Surprised that she pushed it that far? Hell yes. Once again, all I could think about was how this would make Mattix feel if he could understand what this woman was saying. If he could have, then I WOULD have been offended because I don’t want my child to have to sit through that bull sh*t.

I don’t get all crazy when people mistakenly say “own” when they mean biological. I will fully admit. although not proudly, that I’m pretty sure I said that at some point in my pre-adoption life. I think it kind of just comes out of peoples’ mouths. As soon as I started our adoption process and began educating myself, I realized what a big eff up that one is. It’s wrong and the implication for a child who came to their family through adoption is horrible, particularly if the child has bio siblings. However, I recognize that society often makes that distinction – between biological and adopted – and that sometimes people say “own” when they really mean “biological.” So, if someone says that, I usually say something like, “Oh, he is my own. If you mean do we want biological kids, no, we don’t. We’re having our family through adoption.” I’ve had to say that on a number of occasions and it doesn’t bother me because people always get it right away and I don’t think it’s a rude way to nicely correct someone who doesn’t mean to be offensive. I’m pretty sure that just about every time I’ve said that, the person immediately gets it and corrects herself.  Again, the caveat is that Mattix doesn’t understand yet. I have no idea what I’ll do in the future.

Anyway, this was clearly not one of those situation. I gave her a big ol’ handful of free outs and this woman was so pushy and rude that she was wanted to MAKE me say that Mattix wasn’t my “own;” she wanted to MAKE me answer her question. That irritated me.

I was telling a few friends about this later, saying that I was put out because if Mattix could understand, that would be a horrible thing for him to hear. They agreed, then a friend of mine added a point that I had not considered. If we had adopted after suffering a loss or facing infertility, as many adoptive parents do, what that woman did would have been offensive to me, not just to Mattix. A person can love that their family was built through adoption, love their children more than anything in the world, know that they would never do anything differently, and still be sad to have experienced such a significant loss. Beyond her pushing the issue that irritated me on behalf of my son, she was pushing an issue that could have been painful to *me.* And how could she not have known that? Not nice in so many ways.

The next incident happened in a large department store. A sales woman noticed Mattix’s cute squeaky shoes that we bought in Vietnam.  My mom was pushing the stroller and had wandered off somewhere. I was holding Mattix, but at the time, he was walking while holding my fingers so his shoes were squeaking. Here’s how that one went:

Woman: “His shoes are sooo cute!”

Me: “Thank you!”

Woman: “My nephew would love them. Where did you get them?”

Me: “We bought them while we were in Vietnam.”

Woman: “Wow! So you got his shoes in Vietnam????”

Me: “Yeah, we bought several pairs in different sizes because we thought they were neat.”

Woman: {suddenly seems to have an ah ha moment} “Ohhhhh. Is that where ya got him, too?” {pointing to Mattix}

Me: “No, that’s where we GOT the shoes. We ADOPTED him from Vietnam. {smiling, picking up Mattix, and walking away very quickly before my mouth got the better of me…}

Speechless? No. Offended? Not entirely. Shocked? Um, yeah. I’ve never heard anyone refer to my child as though he were something “ya” just “get” while on vacation in a foreign country.

But tonight, Saturday, April 19, 2008, it finally happened. Not only was I speechless, so was my husband. We’re very similar in this area. Ed is actually speechless less often than I am, but tonight, a woman got us both! It came out of left field and it was so simple. Yet it was so weird and crazy that we both just looked at each other.

We were eating dinner at a restaurant a few miles from our house that recently opened. It was such a nice day today that despite the fact that my allergies are so bad my eyes are bloodshot red and my nose is running like a sieve, I insisted we sit on the patio. Our server was a friendly gal, probably in her early to mid-20’s. She had noticed Mattix a few times and commented on how cute he was. Not in that weird sort of way…the way people do it so that you know where it’s going. No, it was just the normal “he’s so cute, look at his hair, ohmygosh, he’s waving at me, how old is he, he’s a doll” sort of thing. So when, after she brought the check to us and said that she’d take it whenever we were ready, she said, “By the way, is he yours?” all sorts of casual, we were seriously speechless. Because that one came out of left field. It was so weird and awkward that the couple sitting at the table next to us actually got silent. It wasn’t that it was offensive. It was just plain weird, out of the blue, what the hell? Ed and I seriously just looked at each other. At some point, I think I got it together enough to say, “Um, yeah.” Then she just said, “Oh,” and turned around and walked back into the restaurant. Then Ed and I of course made a string of smart ass remarks to each other, but for the first time, in, um, our entire lives together, we were both speechless at the same time.

 Not an easy thing to do, trust me.

We’ve gotten lots of looks and questions, but so far, nothing that required me to restrain myself from physically beating someone’s a$$. I’m sure that will all change as Mattix gets older, so if there’s anyone out there with children who are old enough to comprehend conversations, I’d love your advice (Kathy D!). I don’t want to have to beat someone’s a$$ in front of Mattix. (I’m kidding, by the way, in case you think I might do that.)

The nicest way anyone has asked about Mattix occurred at our favorite neighborhood Mexican restaurant. Mattix and I were eating there with a group of my girlfriends and our server was all over Mattix (in a good way). Mattix totally knew it and turned on the charm. They “talked” each and every time he came by the table. Mattix waved and smiled and broke out his fake laugh, his fake smile, and held up his hand for the server to give him “five” over and over. At some point, the man commented on his personality being so dynamic. He asked me how old he was. Then he said, “Where was he born?” so normally, so positively, that I didn’t even pause when I answered him. He then said, “That’s what I thought, but I also thought he might be Cambodian, so I didn’t want to assume.” (That was a very astute observation – I’ll talk about that in another post eventually.) Anyway, he was the nicest guy, totally over the top, and friendly, so the way he asked was quite possibly the most natural way anyone has ever asked about Mattix. I’m certain that if Mattix was old enough to understand, he would have felt very proud – and not like he was on display or like anyone was making an issue of him – to be asked that question. I wish the whole world was like that. It would be a nice world.

 I really am curious how parents of children who are capable of understanding/observing questions and behaviors handle them. The problem with me is that I’m very protective of Mattix and I’d like to be prepared to handle things appropriately when the time comes. I want him to be so proud of who he is and where he’s from, but I also don’t want him to feel like he’s a walking billboard for international adoption. He’s a normal kid who has a very special and amazing history, but that doesn’t mean he has to be an open book about it with every stranger who wants to know. My problem is that I’m going to be protective of him because I’m his mom. My ability to be incredibly sarcastic with a smile on my face to people who are rude,  my ability to remain incredibly calm when I’m pi$$ed beyond words so as not to miss making my point, and my ability to think even more clearly when my head is about to explode, all cause me to worry a bit about my mouth. I think I’m a really nice person. Truly. I have a huge heart and I’d do anything for my friends and family, and I’m very nice to strangers.  But I’m only nice to people I don’t know until they no longer deserve to be on the receiving end of nice. Then I’m not nice at all. HOWEVER, I want to do everything in my power to be a good example to Mattix and to react in such a way that doesn’t make him uncomfortable or feel like he’s on display. Do you ignore people and talk about it later? I know at some point, I’ll be able to take my cues from Mattix, but that won’t happen as quickly as he will able to understand, and this is one of those things I’d rather not learn from my mistakes.

I hope everyone had a great weekend. Mattix, and Ed I are all headed to Kansas City, MO, on Monday, then to St. Louis, MO on Tuesday to finally see our travel mates and friends Karen and Andrew, and Mattix’s KG buddy, Cobra Khai (and maybe a few other people I’d LOVE to see). We’re very excited about this and can’t even wait for the fun! I’ll post with photos, of course.

 

21 Responses

  1. Laura, thanks for stopping by my blog and weighing in. I really enjoyed reading your post on this subject because I need to find some way to respond better. Right now I just feel pissy about it and it’s only a matter of time before I starting sounding pissy also.

    Strangely, I have been asked by a number of people if I want my “own” children. Stranger still is that it has always been a man that has asked. It’s as if they feel I’m being cheated or cheating by adopting. How dare I not take advantage of their “boys”. Whatever.

    Since I am single, I wonder if I will be asked the adoption question as frequently. I live in a diverse town with lots of biracial families…hard to say at this point. But I believe as you do that it is our child’s story and not something that should be conversation for strangers. I’ve always been private and I would not have liked people knowing that information about me.

  2. I can’t say much on this topic, because I’m not really there yet…although I am appalled on your behalf at the gall of some of those exchanges! I like to think it takes a lot to appall me, but apparently, it takes less for me than it does for you…especially the woman in the restaurant.

    I often wonder how to ask people about their (apparently – see below for my explanation of that) adopted children, only because we are adopting and it makes me excited to think that I can talk to adoptive parents IRL! We live in an area with lots and lots of adopted kids and multiracial families. However, I don’t want to offend anyone, so I’ve never once approached anyone. I also have a (white) friend who married a (Korean) guy, and their (biological) baby tends to look more like him at this point, and my friend gets a LOT of rude, “is she yours?” type questions. So it’s not just adopted families – it’s bi/multiracial families, too, that deal with the obnoxious, it’s-none-of-your-business questions.

    I think you handled it well. I’m interested to see what others have to say, too.

  3. I am the same as you in that I am rarely speechless and I don’t really get offended with the random and inappropriate questions. I just try and keep it short and simple and move on. I bet I have been asked 25 times if we want to have our own. Every time it happens, I immediately think of those who have battled infertility for so long and get sad for them. We have not faced that battle, so, like you, it is not offensive to me. Again, EXTREMELY inappropriate, but I can’t say I feel offended.

    I have been asked the exact question of “Is she yours?” many many times. I just say yes and move right along.

    The one time that I was absolutely blown away was in the parking lot of a restaurant. These ladies had been staring at Lucy the entire time we were eating, smiling and clearly talking about how cute she was. They were leaving at the same time as us and came over to say how precious she was. I thanked them and was loading her in the car. Then one of them says, “You are really lucky you got such a pretty one.” I did not repond to this. I can only imagine what my face looked like because she just turned and walked straight to her car. What I should have said was, “You mean, as opposed to getting an ugly one? That would have been unlucky?” I am always stunned by the ignorance of others. I usually end up just feeling really sorry for them.

    Now, totally unrelated but answering your questions on my blog. A playscape is a big outside playground kind of thing. You know, those really really nice wooden ones. Not like our rinky dink plastic ones, but big ones with slides, swings, etc. And you asked about a live out. I giggled at this because what I was saying was that they live out in the country where the girls can be free. I just did not actually say out in the country. Easy to misunderstand though!!

  4. We have had many, many similiar incidents happen with Matthew and now with Marli. Matthew will soon turn 5 and is really starting to understand and ask many questions about how our family has been formed. We have always made sure to talk to Matthew about his “story”, his adoption from the time he came home when he was just 17 months. We are very fortunate that we have a large photo album with Matthew’s baby pictures and also pictures of his birthmother holding him. I tried early on to show him his pictures but he really didn’t seem interested. Well, now he is. Just last week he asked for his “book”, he wanted to talk about how he was in his birthmother’s tummy, and why he was not in mine. Greg and I sit with him for a long time and talked with him about it. Matthew decided he wanted to keep his photo book in his room in a special place, and he looks at it often, and he is talking much more about being in someone elses tummy other than mine, and that discussion is a long one, so I won’t go into the whole thing.

    Now with Matthew being older I do dread the times I know we are fixing to get asked some stupid question, or have some comment made, because this is such a crucial time for Matthew. We have just tried very hard to instill in him a great pride for how our family has been formed and have tried to also make him very proud of where he was born. When asked about our family, I always say “Matthew was born in the Philippines, rather than we adopted him from the Philippines.” I am by no way ashamed of his adoption, I just think it sounds better that way for Matthew right now. Hope that makes sense. We actually had one person ask us if we were going to tell Matthew he is adopted?!?!?!? Of course we should have said “shhhh, no we would never do that!” LOL. That is probably the craziest thing anyone ever said to us, and it was asked by a family member, go figure. Same family member still continues to comment on how well Matthew speaks the English language?!?!? Matthew has been home since he was 17 months old, he will turn 5 in June, so yes he speaks English very well, again crazy!!!

    We too get told all the time about how lucky both our children are, and we always comment back with “no we are the lucky ones.” I just think there will always be ignorant people in this world, that will always think we in some way saved these children, when in reality they saved us. I have always wanted people to just be able to see a family, just a family that loves each other, and not have to look or question how that family was formed. We are just a family, we do the same fun, crazy things every other family does, we are no different, we are no better, just a family. And that is what I hope Matthew and Marli will one day understand that families are formed in many ways, and familes may look different, but we are all very LUCKY to have found one another in this great big world.

  5. Unlike you, I am often speechless and easily offended. Just kidding :) . I am afraid I’ll become that way, though. As usual I have no advice, but I’ll be checking back to see what everyone has to say. Because Sam and Eli are older, I have very little time to figure out the best way to deal with ignorant, intrusive questioning before they’re able to understand exactly what people are saying. I’m dreading it already.

    I hope you enjoy your trip to The Lou! The week is supposed to be nice, so try to make it to the Zoo. (No, I did not intend to make a rhyme). Ever since I’ve known about your impending visit, I’ve been searching through my house to see if Karen has left anything behind that I can return to her while you’re in town :) . If only I had saved the d*mn ball popper Khai took home with him the last time he was here…

  6. Well, I’m not exactly to that point yet, but I’ve always wondered how I would handle these type of situations. I consider myself to be a very nice person until someone ticks me off. Then, not so nice. Should be interesting!

    I’m so excited that you guys are going to visit Khai and the fam! Have fun!

  7. I so hear you! Ever since I read Harlow’s Monkey’s post about being an adoption poster child I have been mulling all of this over. It is our son’s story, but others don’t allow them to decide whether they want to share it. They just bust in and comment. It SO pisses me off. You were totally right with your point about infertility. We went through it and I still have people say “He’s adopted right? Can you not have any kids?” UMMMM kid sitting right here and he is mine!!! It is really annoying and I too wonder about “educating” others in front of him vs. talking about it after the fact. It is a fine line indeed… CANNOT WAIT TO SEE YOU GUYS!!!

  8. People need to learn that, sometime adoption is a choice, regardless. adoption is a beautiful thing, which is very meaningfull to the parents and child, either you recognize it, or practice “silence is golden”, you can talk to Mattix, let him know that he is God’s gift, a special child, delivered from an exotic land and placed in your heart as your chosen child. “Childbirth is an act of nature, adoption is an act of love”, tell him, always remember that when people make obnoxious comments. Enjoy your road trip.

  9. What an awesome post! Thank you!!

    As you know we are still waiting to travel, but just bringing up the fact we are adopting our baby gets the Crazies out! 99.9% of the time the first and only reaction is happiness for us, etc. But we have gotten some really good ones. The standard “Will you have your own?” “He’s going to be such a lucky baby” (We answer as you do). The new one I’ve gotten twice has been ” Well you know how it goes! 6 months after you get him home you’ll be pregnant!” As if this is somehow ‘better’ or more ‘desired’? I set both people straight- that 1. that’s really not appropriate to say and 2. we are madly in love with out son and wouldn’t change a thing. The worst comment so far was about 3 months ago. a colleague I don’t work with much said, “That’s so sad. Don’t you even want to try and get pregnant?” I am usually quite private about certain things so but I said (with a smile), ‘That’s a pretty ***ed up thing to say, Marilyn. Losing our pregnancy was sad, but adopting our son is the happiest thing we have ever and will ever do. Have a *great* day!”
    It leaves me wondering how I will be when our baby is old enough to comprehend what’s being said, about him, us, etc. I am usually a pretty calm and polite person, but this gets me a little nuts.

  10. Hey,

    I was just browsing by.
    I guess I;m from a completely different part of the world here in India, but guess what? Same same same comments all the time. The “is she yours” questions don’t bother me, and I don’t even turn a hair about the “have your ‘own’ children” question (though the adoption was due to infertility in our case)… what gets me is people telling me how lucky the kids are, and how god will bless me for doing this “noble” deed. I’m like: he already blessed me, it’s me/us who’s lucky for having these wonderful kids.
    Sigh.
    That and, the other well-meaning folks who say how lucky we are for taking the “shortcut” of adoption as opposed to the painstaking process of pregnancy and delivery. Yeah, if that’s lucky, I wish they get that great good luck themselves next time.

  11. WOW. You really have had some questions! We haven’t had that many (thank goodness), but we have had a few. It’s the comments that bug me. The worst? The “he’s so lucky” one. Even my father-in-law said it. And I said, NO, we’re the lucky ones. NO, he said, HE is. Good Grief. I said. WE don’t think of it that way. The other one is, “You’re adopting? Oh, I’m so proud of you!” HUH? Proud of me? What tha? For what? For selflessly saving a child from a terrible life? Hardly! We’re doing this for totally selfish reasons. WE WANT A CHILD. OR TWO. WE ARE NOT TRYING TO SAVE THE WORLD. So please, don’t be proud of me. It’s insulting to my son(s).

    Once, before our first son came home, an older guy in my office said, “Friends of ours adopted a little boy from Korea, too.” Then he added, apologetically, “Of course, he’s Asian….but that’s okay.” ! Sheesh.

    Regarding the “Don’t you want your own?” questions, I always say, “Do you mean biological? Because he’s very much ‘our own’” and they say “yes.” I think they mean nothing by it, and our job is to educate people whenever they say it in that way.

    We were at breakfast one time at a restaurant. Our server (they’re not called waitressess anymore), looked at our son in his stroller and said as she knelt down beside him, “He’s beautiful.” I said thank you and she said very kindly, “What are his origins?” I said, “He’s from Korea.” “He’s just beautiful,” she repeated. I said “thanks.” It was nice. You don’t get those very often, but when you do, you remember them always.

    Sorry, this was a longer comment than I anticipated. Clearly, you touched on something everyone has an opinion on or experience with. Treat ignorance with humor–enlighten them and move on. Bless you for sharing!

  12. We’ve had all those same encounters. Just yesterday we had one of those speechless restaurant encounters. I was at a book sale with my whole family and I had Addy separated from the rest of my gang and put her down to play and she started yelling for Noah, I tried to point her in the right direction and the lady next to me immediately assumed she was lost and could not find her mother and bent over to help her find her lost mother which really bugged me on many levels. I’ve also had the “are you the nanny” bit at her mommy and me gymnastics class. Lately, though, I mostly get comments about my entire family, wondering if they are all adopted or if Noah was my only biological child. 99.9% of the time I try to assume that ignorance is an opportunity for learning and I just put in their mouths what they MEANT to say. Like “I think you meant to say biological children, right? because any child who comes into our family will be our “own” child, regardless of biology or adoption.”. I think by rephrasing things for people, it gives them some enlightenment on what they said wrong and how to properly state it. I also know that I feel *paralyzed* by an inability to approach other adoptive or transracial families because I don’t know how others will take it so I try to always be kind no matter how deeply offended I am. I don’t have older children but I also think it is important to role-model the kind of person I want my children to be and NOT be overly defensive. I don’t want my kids to be overly defensive about their race or adoption status. I want them to be tolerant, understanding and to educate others. So this is what I try to model. I think all of your responses were perfect, btw! I think Mattix will do very well with those kinds of responses when he is older.

  13. Oh wow!
    As you know, I have dealt with a bit of this myself lately.
    Before we adopted Thanh, I read that families who adopt are sometimes offended by questions people asked, and I was curious about that. I wasn’t sure if I would be offended, so I’ve tried to notice my comfort level and, like you, think about how a question will sound when Thanh is a bit older, vs. a toddler. Often folks are just curious and ask general questions, which I don’t mind. I am comfortable talking about how long we waited, what good care Thanh received from her caregivers, that we spent 2 weeks in Vietnam, etc.
    My nephew had some really hurtful things to say, which I know he had heard from his mother (estranged from the family), and that was really hard for me. Even though he is only 10-yesars-old I was really upset. I was concerned that I would never be able to leave the two of them alone together, but our recent visits have gone better. I do not want Thanh to grow up hearing that cr#p from her cousin.
    I have found that specific questions about Thanh’s birth family really rub me the wrong way. Those questions feel too personal. I usually do not answer them.
    When someone comments about Thanh being “lucky”, I comment that we are all lucky to be a family, and that has always ended it.
    Recently a white woman approached me in the science museum and asked if my husband is Asian. I was a bit taken aback, and said, “No.” She replied, “Oh, my husband is Asian, so I was just wondering.” I didn’t mind that, because that woman was looking at me as someone who may have something in common with her. I felt fine casually chatting with her for a minute. But I think that same question from someone else might feel really personal.
    I could go on and on…. Sorry you had to deal with all of those inappropriate comments! Have a great vacation.

  14. Well, I haven’t BTDT, so I was very interested in all of the comments left! I am the type who is usually speechless or, I come up with a bunch of smart a$$ comments AFTER it happens. I don’t think my pre-adoptive class on this topic will work in all situations. In today’s world, it amazes me how ignorant some people are…okay, maybe not. Sorry you had to deal with this stuff- sounds like you did a good job to me!

  15. Ok, the guy in the Mexican restaurant totally made me cry! How sweet that he got it exactly right. I hope you tipped him B.I.G.

    I’m not sure why, but in the 3 years Grace has been with me, we’ve never had anything happen. Maybe people assume I’m single and assume Grace is adopted and that’s it. My mom has had questions when it’s been just the two of them, but never anything rude or inappropriate. I know it will happen one day and I’m sure I’ll be totally caught off guard. I was armed and ready when we were a new family, now, I don’t think too much about it.

    Have fun in MO. Do we have to move away to see you? lol For sure when you’re back. Have fun. K

  16. Hi Laura – You know I generally don’t comment, but you really brought up some great questions. I am trying to remember my own childhood in hopes to offer something useful. Blank. ;) But, seriously, I agree with Nicki. From what I recall, my mom always handled it with politeness, but a sense of humor as well. As I got older (6, 7, 8, etc), she and I would giggle about it afterwards. Her grace in handling the situation has probably greatly influenced how i handle ‘adoption’ questions even today. Her natural responses made me feel comfortable with who I was and my story. She would also explain to me that everyone’s different and they may not be familiar with adoption. That they might just be curious, even if they don’t ask the questions the “right” way. I always *assume* they don’t mean harm and might be slightly uncomfortable and at a loss for words – hence their words come out wrong.

    Another thought – I also think as adults we are ultra-sensitive to some of the nuances (i.e. “get” and “yours”) and it’s possible our children won’t pick up on it. Don’t get me wrong, I do think it’s important to be aware of it… but I don’t ever recall hearing a lot of those, even though I’m sure my mom was asked the same things (especially 30 years ago when adoption wasn’t nearly as common or accepted). Maybe it was because she didn’t make a big deal over it, not sure.

    I know you mentioned Mattix’s life not being an open book to strangers. It’s funny you should mention that cuz I had a post brewing in my mind about something similar. I’m generally a very private person, but in my experience my adoption is THE one thing I’ve learned to be open about (which I’m totally fine with). Even when I go to a doctor it’s one of the first things you mention (Q: What’s your family history? A: I’m adopted.). People will always ask. They do feel it’s their right to know my story, but I’ve realized it’s much easier to talk about it then go through a lifetime of uncomfortable moments.

    Not sure if any of this was helpful (or linear!), but just my 2 cents. I’m sure you’ll be awesome, though – half the battle is awareness. :) — tina

  17. This is a great post.

    I was worried about how to respond to people’s questions, but, honestly, people rarely ask us about this when Lana is with us, and I truly think it’s because she is obviously old enough to understand.

    I did have one horrible experience in a hospital emergency room that I really don’t think I can talk about right now cause it makes me want to hit someone…but, essentially, at first they were going to refuse to treat my daughter because I didn’t have my adoption decree with me…I’m glad she didn’t understand the things that person was saying about her…(she had only been in the US a few weeks at the time.)

    We have had people assume that Lana belonged to another family we were standing next to (the family was Asian)…that was weird, and Lana flung herself at my husband yelling, ‘THIS IS MY DADDY. HIM NOT MY DADDY! (pointing to the Asian dad of the other family.)

    Gretchen

  18. My children were born to my first husband and I. We are two different races. We divorced, only for me to remarry when my baby was 18 months old , and the girls were 8 and 12. The man I married was an entirely different racial and ethnic backgound. But to this day I still remember people commenting upon how nice it was of me to marry a man with a ready made family. Even today we have people that swear we were lying that these were my children, how they were surely adopted.

    One more comment on my first born. In the grocery a lady noticed how dark my daughter was, so she asked. What nationally is she? American I replied. What country was her father from? America I replied. She huffed and puffed. I want to let loose on her but I could not.
    My children have been questioned all their lives if they are adopted…those were not…but the last three were. One is from a Mexican Indian black caucasian mix, and the other two are from a Philippino negrito and a Japanese white mix.
    Only our middle child, if there is a middle to 7 child, is our mix, and he is the only one that looks even a little like me. The rest of the kiddos got Dads looks, but my brains , ha!
    See adopted or birthed people can be so off.
    We have a waitess in the Pizza Hut who is so genuine with us. She lets our two little girls pass all the time cause they hardly eat enough to keep a fly alive….One day when I was totally frustrated with soc security and getting ID cards, she commented that she could help but over hear us, and that she knew how we felt because her mother has to get her visa renewed every ten years. Now we all turned to look at her a second look. We assumed she was a white American. She went on to share with us her father had married while stationed in Korea her mother, and she her self had grown up in the Hawaiian Is. She shared with us her own valuable lessons. We deemed it a better day than if we had waltzed into soc sec and waltzed out.

  19. Last year my husband and I adopted a 4 year-old girl, who was born in Russia (the phrase we use). She has a huge facial deformity, so we constantly get the comments about how lucky she was to be adopted by us and what angels we are etc. I usually just keep on talking as if the comment was never made. Today, after the follow-up visit to her second surgery, her doctor commented on how her face was changing and commented that she is starting to look “like she could be yours!” I just smiled to myself; that was a new one! I just can’t take offense at this stuff, although I’m sure someone will come up with the one that breaks the camel’s back at some point! Mind you, the woman that kept pushing the “your own” thing would certainly have come close. I just remind myself that people really don’t get it…and quite honestly, I have said some pretty dumb things myself about situations when I didn’t know any better.

  20. [...] the people who make stupid comments or ask inappropriate ignorant questions, the type I wrote about HERE. Rather, I’m talking about perfectly reasonable, well intentioned, respectful people who [...]

  21. i’m a first timer on the website and just want to say THANK you for sharing your stories. i have learnt so much and still have so much to learn with BOTH my girls. Giving birth and Adopting has taught me one thing – “However motherhood comes to you, it is a miracle!!”

    the weirdest comment i have heard is about how our youngest sounds exactly like her older sister (their accents)… why wouldn’t they sound alike? the eldest is ours through biological and the youngest is ours through adoption.

    We live in South Africa and have had most of the comments already that is mentioned in the post above. with some i was speechless, but i feel more empowered now that i have read some responses that i can use without losing my cool.

Leave a Reply